- Wellness Roll Up
- Posts
- Andrew Huberman, Ph.D., with Dr. Lauren Colenso-Semple, Ph.D., Explains: Women Don’t Need a “Special” Workout — They Need Progressive Overload
Andrew Huberman, Ph.D., with Dr. Lauren Colenso-Semple, Ph.D., Explains: Women Don’t Need a “Special” Workout — They Need Progressive Overload
Why the science says women should train almost exactly like men — and what actually matters for muscle, fat loss, hormones, and long-term health.
If you want to hear the full conversation, watch the complete episode here and then come back to this breakdown for the most actionable takeaways.
On this episode of the Huberman Lab Podcast, neuroscientist Andrew Huberman, Ph.D., sits down with Dr. Lauren Colenso-Semple, Ph.D., an integrative physiologist and strength and conditioning specialist who studies muscle growth, hormones, and exercise science.
The big headline?
Women do not need a fundamentally different training program than men.
And that’s not opinion — that’s what the data say.
But the nuance is where things get interesting.
The Biggest Myth: “Women Need Sex-Specific Training”
There’s a powerful narrative in fitness right now:
Women need different rep ranges
Women need cycle-based programming
Women shouldn’t lift heavy
Women shouldn’t train fasted
Women shouldn’t train during certain phases
Women shouldn’t do high intensity because of “cortisol”
According to Dr. Colenso-Semple, the majority of this does not align with the data.
At the muscle level:
Men and women respond similarly to resistance training
Muscle protein synthesis is similar
Relative hypertrophy response is similar
The primary difference?
Men start with higher baseline muscle mass due to testosterone exposure during puberty. But once training begins, relative gains are comparable.
ACTIONABLE TAKEAWAY #1
Women Should Train for Muscle — Not Just Weight Loss
Historically, women have been told exercise is for shrinking.
Dr. Colenso-Semple reframes this:
Resistance training is about growing muscle — not getting smaller.
Why this matters:
Muscle improves body composition
Muscle protects bone density
Muscle reduces fall and fracture risk
Muscle preserves independence with aging
And most importantly:
Pilates and walking alone are not enough to prevent age-related muscle loss.
She emphasizes that just two 20-minute full-body resistance sessions per week can meaningfully slow muscle decline.
What to Do This Week:
Add 2 full-body resistance sessions (minimum)
Focus on progressive overload (more reps or more load over time)
Stop chasing soreness — chase progression
How Women Should Structure Training (Simple Framework)
For most people training 2–3x per week:
Full Body Routine
2–4 hard sets per major muscle group
Train close to failure (1–2 reps in reserve)
6–12 rep range works well for most exercises
Rest ~2 minutes between sets
If training 4+ days:
Upper/lower split works great
No need for:
“Female rep ranges”
High-rep-only programs
Pink dumbbells
The Menstrual Cycle Question
This is where the internet gets loud.
Should women train differently during different phases of their cycle?
Dr. Colenso-Semple’s answer:
No — not by default.
The data do not support overhauling training based purely on hormone fluctuations.
What DOES make sense:
If you feel awful for 1–2 days, adjust.
If performance feels harder, that’s okay — objective output may be unchanged.
Don’t preemptively downshift your training because an app says you’re in the luteal phase.
ACTIONABLE TAKEAWAY #2
Train Based on Performance — Not Calendar Phases
Instead of cycle-syncing your whole program:
Track your strength numbers.
See if performance actually changes.
Adjust only if symptoms meaningfully interfere.
Most women reporting menstrual symptoms do not overhaul their training.
That’s important.
Cardio: Do You Need It?
Here’s the refreshing take:
You don’t need structured cardio if:
You lift 2–3x/week
You hike, bike, play sports, or move regularly
The “interference effect” (cardio blunting muscle growth) only becomes meaningful with very high training volumes.
For general health:
Stay physically active.
Choose cardio you enjoy.
Don’t add cardio just to burn calories — fat loss is primarily nutritional.
Cortisol Panic: Let’s Clear This Up
You’ve probably heard:
“HIIT raises cortisol.”
“Zone 2 raises cortisol.”
“Cold plunges raise cortisol.”
“Cortisol makes you store belly fat.”
Here’s the reality:
Exercise naturally raises cortisol.
That is normal.
That is necessary.
Cushing syndrome (pathologically high cortisol) is rare and not comparable to normal training-induced spikes.
Most “cortisol belly fat” is:
Excess calories
Stress-related eating
Poor sleep
Inactivity
Not the workout.
ACTIONABLE TAKEAWAY #3
Stop Avoiding Intensity Because of Cortisol
Lift heavy if you want to.
Sprint if you enjoy it.
Train hard.
Acute cortisol spikes from exercise do not cause midsection fat gain.
Fasted Training: Does It Matter?
The verdict:
Long-term muscle and fat loss outcomes are similar whether you train fed or fasted.
Choose based on preference.
Fasted feels better? Go for it.
Small carb snack feels better? Fine.
The 30-minute anabolic window? Overblown.
Protein synthesis remains elevated long after training.
Creatine for Women
Dr. Colenso-Semple supports creatine monohydrate:
~5g per day
Safe
Well studied
Can improve performance slightly
Avoid gummies — many are underdosed.
Brain benefits? Promising in clinical populations, but not proven as a universal cognitive enhancer yet.
Menopause & Hormones
Important nuance:
Hormone therapy can be effective for symptom relief (sleep, hot flashes)
But:
It is not proven to prevent cognitive decline.
It is not a muscle-building shortcut.
It is not a guaranteed longevity tool.
Testosterone for muscle in women?
Low doses may be prescribed for libido, but not as a proven muscle enhancer
The Most Powerful Theme of the Episode
Dr. Colenso-Semple puts it plainly:
If there were clear, science-backed reasons women needed fundamentally different training, she would recommend it.
The data show:
Women respond to resistance training similarly to men.
The basics work.
Progressive overload works.
Consistency works.
The complicated stuff often just adds confusion.
Your 7-Day Reset Plan
If you’ve been overcomplicating fitness:
This week:
Lift your full body twice.
Train 6–12 reps close to failure.
Track progression.
Walk daily or do enjoyable movement.
Eat sufficient protein.
Sleep.
Stop blaming cortisol.
That’s it.
If you want evidence-based health and fitness breakdowns like this, without the noise, fear tactics, or trendy overcomplication, subscribe to Wellness Rollup.
We distill the science so you can train smarter, live longer, and stop second-guessing your health decisions.